徘徊在十字路口的中国法学

威尼斯官方网站ZHEIGETIMU,XIANDEYOUDIANWEIYANSONGTING: ZHONGGUOFAXUEBUSHIZHENGYIRIQIANLI、KUOBUQIANXINGMA?YUWEIBUXIN,KEDAOFAXUESHUDIANNEILINLANGMANMUDESHUJIASHANG、HUOGELEISHUDIANDEFAXUEZHUANJUQIANKANYIXIAA。SHIDE,ZHIYAOBAOYOUGONGYUNLICHANGDEREN,JUEBUHUIDUIERSHIYUNIANLAI,TEBIESHI1988NIANYILAIZHONGGUOFAXUEDEJIANNANFAZHAN、CHUANGXINSHIERBUJIAN。BENWENQIANGDIAOZHONGGUOFAXUEPAIHUAIZAISHIZILUKOU,QIAHAOSHIZAIDUIZHEIYIRENSUOGONGJIANDEJINBUKENDINGJICHUSHANGDELILUN。

SHIZILUKOU,DAOLUZONGHENG,DONGXINANBEIYANSHEN,SHIMEIMEILINGBUZHIJIULIDEXINGRENZUOGUYOUPAN、ZHIZHUPAIHUAIZHISUO。TAYIBANYIWEIZHE: RENMENYIJINGZOUGUOLEXIANGDANGZHANGDEYIDUANLU,DANDANGXUNQIUMUBIAODERENMENYUDAOZHEIGESHIZILUKOUSHI,QIXUANZEZHINENGSHI: YAOMEYUANDIBUDONG,YAOMEZOURUCHALU,YAOMEZHITONGMUBIAO。

SHUNIANQIAN,YOURENJIUTICHU“ZHONGGUOFALIXUEXIANGHECHUQU”DEWENTI,BINGZAIQUANGUOFANWEINEIZUZHIYIXIEXUEZHEJINXINGYANTAO[1]。JINGUANWEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANDUIZHEIYANGDETIWENBUYIWEIRAN,DANRUGUOHUANYIZHONGSHUOFA,JIZHONGGUOFAXUEQUESHIMIANLINZHESHIZILUKOUSHANGDEJUEZEZELIYINGBEIJIESHOU。NEIME,DANGDAIZHONGGUOFAXUEJINGGUOLEERSHIYUNIANDECHIXUFAZHAN,JINTIANSUOMIANLINDESHIZILUKOUJIUJINGSHISHENME?WEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANRENWEI: RUXIAWENTIHUOKEJIESHUOZHEIZHONGSHIZILUKOU:

“ZHONGGUOFAXUE”[2]JIUJINGYAOCHIXUBUDUANDIYIFANYIWAIBANGZUOPINWEIZHUHAISHIGENJUZHONGGUOFAZHIXUYAOTUCHUZIJIDE“GONGXIAN”?“ZHONGGUOFAXUE”YINGDANGKUANRONGBUTONGXUESHUQINGXIANGDEGUANDIANZAIFAXUEJIAOYUZHONGDUOYUANZHANXIAN,HAISHIJIXUDINGYUYIZUN,YOUBIANXIANGDE“GUANFANG”LAIQINDINGJIAOCAI?“ZHONGGUOFAXUE”YAOJINGENSHIJIANHAISHICHAOYUESHIJIAN……

威尼斯官方网站ZHEIYANGKANLAI,“ZHONGGUOFAXUE”SUOMIANDUIDEBUJINSHISHIZILUKOU,SHENHUOSHIMIZILUKOU、QILUZONGHENGDELUKOU……JIUSHANGSHUWENTIBENSHENERYAN,YEXUYIBANHUIDASHI: ZHEIXIEWENTIBINGBUMAODUNA。DANZAIWEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANKANLAI,MAODUNHENTUCHU:

SHOUXIAN,RUGUOWEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANXUANZELECHIXUBUDUANDIYIFANYIWAIBANGDEFAXUEZHUZUOWEIZHU,NEIME,ZHISHAOYOUYIGELINIANZAIZHICHENG,NEIJIUSHIWEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANSUOFANYIDEWAIBANGDELILUNBIGUORENZISHENDEXUELIYANJIUHUIGENGHAODIJIEJUEZHONGGUODEWENTI,YUCIXIANGGUANLIAN,YEYOUYIGEJIBENDEPANDUAN: ZHONGGUORENBUKENENGCHUANGZAOCHUZHICHIQIFAZHIWEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANDELILUN。HAOWUYIWEN,ZIJINSHIYILAI,ZHONGGUOGEMENXUEWENDEFAZHAN,JIBENSHANGYIJING“XIYANGHUA”LE,JISHIZAIZHONGGUOXUEWENCHUANTONGZHONGDUZHANAOTOUDEWEN、SHILIANGKE,CONGQIGAINIANFANCHOUDAOQIYANJIUFANSHI,JIEBEI“XIYANGHUA”LE。JINGUANZAISHIXUEJIE,YOURENHAIZAIYUNYONG“QIANJIAKAOJU”ZHIXUESHENZUANXIYAN,DANTAZAOYICHENGWEISHIXUEFANGFAZHIQIANGNUZHIMO,QUESHIBUZHENGDESHISHI。ZHIYUFAXUEZHEIZHONGZAIJIUYOUDEGUOXUEZHONGBENLAIBUZHANDUODADIWEIDEXUEWEN,JIUSHOUXIYANGYINSUDEYINGXIANGGENGDA,SHENZHIWEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANMUQIANBENLAIJIUZHIYOU“XIYANGFAXUEZAIZHONGGUO”,ERBUCUNZAI“ZHONGGUOFAXUE”。JIAZHISUOWEI“FAZHIHUA”GUOCHENGGUIGENJIEDINAISHIYUANZIXIFANGJINDAISHEHUIJIEGOUDECHANWU[3],ZHEIJIUGENGJIASHENLEWEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANDUIJIEZHUXIYANGFAXUEYIJIEJUEZHONGGUOWENTIDEDANGRANLUOJITUILUNHEZIXINPANDUAN。RANER,WENTIZONGYOUTADELINGYIMIAN,JIWEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANDEWENTIZONGSHIZHONGGUODE。

YUSHI,FAXUEXUERENMENKAISHIGUANZHUZHONGGUOFAXUEJIADEGONGXIANSHISHENME。KEYIKENDING,ZHEIZHONGGUANZHUNAISHIDUIZHONGGUOFAZHIWEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANGUANQIEDECHANWU。YINWEIWEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANYUELAIYUEFAXIANZAIZHONGGUOZHEIYANGYIGEWENHUAYOUJIU、FUYUANLIAOKUO、DIFANGGUANXIJIQIFUZADEGUODU,QIFAZHIWEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANZHONGDEZHONGGUOYINSUBUDANDALIANGCUNZAI,CONGERCHUNCUIDE“FALVYIZHI”ZUIDUOZHINENGJINZHIFALVGUIZELINGYU,ERWUFAYUFALVGUIZEYIQITONGSHIJINZHIRENMENDEJIAOWANGXINGWEILINGYU,BINGJINERQUDERENMENDEXINLIRENTONG。ZHEIZHONGSHISHIQIANGLIEDICIJIZHEYIXIEFAXUEJIAMENKAISHIGUANZHUZHONGGUOWENTI,YANJIUZHONGGUOFALV,CHUANGZAOYOUBIEYUCONGWAIBANGYINRUDEZHONGGUOFAXUE。JINGUANZAIZHEIYIGUOCHENGZHONG,RENMENBUKEBIMIANDIRENGRANZAIJIEYONGLAIZIXIYANGDEFAXUESHUYU、FAXUEFENXIGONGJU,DANQINEIXINGUANQIE,QUESHISHIZAIZAIDIMIANXIANGLEZHONGGUODEWENTI。BINGQIEZAIZHONGGUODEWENTIZHONGXUNQIUXINDEFAXUEXUESHUFANCHOUHEFANSHI。ZAIWEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANKANLAI,ZHEIZHONGDUIZHONGGUOWENTIZHISHENQIEGUANZHUJIQIZAIZHONGGUOWENTIJICHUSHANGDUIFAXUEYANJIUFANCHOUHEFANSHIDEXUNQIUHECHUANGXIN,YINGDANGSHIZHONGGUOFAXUEJIANULIDEZHUYAOFANGXIANG,ZHEIYIFANGMIANZAIYUZUOWEIZHONGGUOFAXUEJIADEYINGYOUWENHUAQINGJIE;LINGYIFANGMIANZEZAIYUZHONGGUODEWENTIBUJINSHUYUZHONGGUO,CONGQIYONGYOUSHIJIEWUFENZHIYIRENKOUZHEIGEJIBENSHISHIZHONG,WEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANKEYIXIANMINGDISHUOTAYESHUYUSHIJIE。YINCI,YIWEIWEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANZHIYAOFANYILEZUGOUDEXIFANGFAXUEZUOPIN,ZHONGGUODEFAZHIWEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANWENTI、SHENZHIZHONGGUODEFAXUEBENSHENJIUYINGRENERJIELE,JISHIBUNENGSHUOSHIBUQIESHIJIDEHUANXIANG,DANZHISHAOYEYOUGUOFENLEGUANZHIXIAN。YINCI,WEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANZHUZHANGYINGQIANGDIAOZHONGGUODANGDAIFAXUEJIADEGONGXIANSHISHENME——BUJINWEILEZHONGGUOFAXUEHEFAZHI,ERQIEWEILESHIJIEFAXUEHEFAZHI。

威尼斯官方网站QICI,FAXUEJIAOYU、TEBIESHIGAODENGFAXUEJIAOYU,BIAOXIANZHEYIGEGUOJIAFAXUEFAZHANDEJIBENZHUANGKUANG。YINCI,ZAIGAODENGFAXUEJIAOYUZHONGJIUJINGCAIQUHEZHONGJIAOCAI——TEBIESHILILUNFAXUEJIAOCAI?SHIGENJUMOUZHONGZHENGZHIYISHIXINGTAIHUOZHEYIXIEBUMEN、CHUBANDANWEIJI“ZHIMINGZHUANJIA”DELONGDUANLIYIERYAOQIUBIANZUANTONGYIDEFAXUEJIAOCAITIXINI,HAISHIGENJUXUESHUYANJIUDEXIANSHIZHUANGKUANGCAIQUDUOYUANHUADEJIAOCAITIXI?ZHEISHIHENGLIANGYIGEGUOJIAFAXUEFAZHANKAIFANGCHENGDUDEZHONGYAOCANZHAO,YESHINENGFOUYIDUOYUANDEXUESHUHEJIAOYUZHICHIFAZHIWEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANDEXUESHUZHICHENG。

BANIANQIAN,BIZHEJIUQIANGDIAOFAXUEJIAOCAIDUOYUANHUADUIFAXUEFAZHANDEZHONGYAOXING[4]。JINTIAN,ZHEIZHONGZHUZHANGYIRAN。RUGUOSHUOXIRIDEZHUZHANGZHUYAOSHIZHENDUIYISHIXINGTAIHUOZHEMOUZHONGXIANSHIZHENGZHIDEYINGXIANGERYANDEHUA,NEIME,ZAIJINTIANJIUSHIZHONGTI,SHIYINWEICHIFAXUEJIAOCAIYIYUANHUADEZHUZHANGYOUYOUSUOTAITOUBINGYOULEXINDELIYOU: WEILESHUOSHIHUOBOSHIYANJIUSHENGKAOSHI;HUOZHEWEILEQUANGUOTONGYIDESIFAKAOSHI。ZHANGQIYILAI,JIANCHIMOUZHONGYINGSHIJIAOYUYIJINGXINGCHENGWEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANZAIJIAOYUFANGMIANDEYAWENHUATEZHENGHEJIAOYUEXI。CONGXIAOXUEDAOZHONGXUESHIRUCI,JINTIAN,YOUJINER“CHUANRAN”DAOLEDAXUEJIAOYUZHONG[5],DUICI,WEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANJISHIBUNENGSHUOSHIJIAOYUSHIYEDEBEIJU,DANZHISHAOYESHIKEBEIDESHI。

RENCAIDEPEIYANG,GUIZAIBUJUYIGE。TANJICI,WEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANDOUHUIXIANGQIGONGZIZHENNEIZHENLONGFAKUIDESHIJU: “JIUZHOUSHENGQISHIFENGLEI,WANMAQIYINJIUKEAI。WEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANQUANTIANGONGZHONGDOUSOU,BUJUYIGEJIANGRENCAI”。FAXUEJINGUANYOUQIGONGLIXINGDENEIRONG,DANZUOWEIYIZHONGSHEHUIXIANXIANG,RENMENWANGWANGYIQI“QIANJIAN”ZUOWEIFAXUESIKAODEJICHU。“QIANJIAN”DECHAYI,YIWEIZHEFAXUEJIANSHIDEYOUBIE。ZAIBUTONG“QIANJIAN”ZHICHIXIADEBUTONGFALVJIANSHI,GEZIDAIBIAOZHEBUTONGDEXUESHUZHUZHANG、XUESHULINIANHEDUIFALVDERENZHIFANGXIANG,TAMENWANGWANGZHIYOUSHIJIAOHEFANGXIANGZHIQUBIE,ERMEIYOUCUOWUHEZHENGQUEZHIFENJIE。DUIYUGAODENGFAXUEJIAOYUERYAN,ZHIYOUBINGCHIXUESHUKAIFANG、JIANSHOUBINGXUDELICHANGHETAIDU,CAIYOUKENENGJIPEIYUXUESHENGKAIKUODEXUESHUHEZHISHISHIYE,YEJIAOQIXUEHUIZIWEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANSIKAO、ZIWEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANPANDUAN,CONGERZHENZHENGCHENGWEI“WEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANAIWEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANSHI,WEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANGENGAIZHENLI”ZHUTIXINGCUNZAI,ERBUSHIGENZHELAOSHIYIYANGHUAHULUDE“KETIHUA”CUNZAI。

DANGRAN,YUCIXIANGYINGDESHI: JIAOCAIDEBIANXIESHIZHONGYAODE。MUXIADEQINGXINGSHI: ZAIFAXUEJIE,SUOWEI“QUANGUOXINGJIAOCAI”DEBIANXIE,YIRANCHENGWEIYIXIESHOUDAOMOUGEBUMENSHANGSHIDEDANGHONGZHUANJIAHEZHEIXIEBUMEN、CHUBANSHELIANSHOULONGDUANDE“ZHUANLI”,TEBIEZHIDEZHUYIDESHIZHEIXIEJIAOCAIWANGWANGYINWEIFUHELEMOUGEBUMENSUOQINDINGDEJIAOCAIYAOQIU,YEJIUQIANGZHIXINGDIXINGCHENG“MAIFANGSHICHANG”。JISHIYOUXIEHENYOUCHUANGYIDE“DIFANGJIAOCAI”,YEBUDEBUYINGHEZHEIZHONGQINDINGDEYAOQIU。LIRU,YOUBENXIANGDANGBUCUODEGERENZHUANXIEDEFALIXUEJIAOCAIZAIFENGDIZHEIYANGXIEZHE: “BENSHUHANGAILEGUOJIAJIAOWEI《FALIXUEZHIDAOGANGYAO》GUIDINGDEZHISHIDIAN……”[6]ZHENGSHIZHEIZHONGQINGXING,DAOZHIZAISUOWEI“QUANGUOXINGJIAOCAI”ZHIWAIDE“DIFANGXINGJIAOCAI”DEBIANXIE,WANGWANGSHIGAOXIAOZHONGZUIWUYANJIUNENGLIDEYIXIERENZAILANYUCHONGSHUDIBIANXIE!ZHEIXIELIANYIPIANXIANGYANGDEPUJIXINGWENZIYEXIEBUCHULAIDE“XUEZHE”,JURANMEIMEICHENGWEIDAXUEFAXUEJICHUJIAOCAIDE“ZHUBIAN”ZHE,YICIYUREN,MIANQIANGBUWURENZIDI,JIUSUANWANXING。ZHIYUZAICIZHONGJIAOCAIZHIZHOUXIA,QIWANGNENGPEIYANGCHUYIPIPIJUYOUZHUOYUEJIANJIEDECHUANGZAOXINGFAXUERENCAI,ZEWUYIYUCHIRENSHUOMENG。YIBENRENSIJIAN,YINGJIJIGULIXUEYOUCHENGJIUDEFAXUEJIABAZIJIDECHENGSHUDEYANJIUNEIRONGBIANXIECHENGJIANJIEGEYIDEJIAOCAI,ZHUGUANBUMENZHIYUYIZHENGCEXINGDIAOKONG,ZHIYUJIAOCAIDEQIANJING,HAISHIJIAOYOURENMENDEXUYAOHESHICHANGQUDIAOJIEBA。

威尼斯官方网站ZUIHOU,FAXUEJIUJINGYAOJINGENSHIJIANHAISHICHAOYUEYUSHIJIAN。ZHEIYESHIYIGELAOSHENGCHANGTANDEWENTI。ZAI1994NIANYUDALIANZHAOKAIDEYICIHUIYISHANG,DANGYOURENTANJI“LILUNLIANXISHIJI”SHI,WEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANZHICHU,DANGXIAWEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANDEZHENGJIE,QIAQIAZAIYULILUNGUODULIANXISHIJI,ZAIQIANGDIAO“LILUNLIANXISHIJI”DETONGSHI,QIEMOWANGJI“SHIJIANLIANXILILUN”[7]。SHISHISHANG,LILUNLIANXISHIJISHIYIZHONGLILUNCHUANGSHENGGUOCHENGZHONGDEBIRANYAOQIU。DANLILUNBIXUYUANYUSHIJIBINGGAOYUSHIJI。JIUFAXUEYAN,YIDANQIJINJINSHIFALVSHIJIANDE“XIESHI”[8],ZETASHENMEYEBUSHI。SHEXIANGBANDEFALVSHIJIANXIESHI,LIUSHUISHIDESIFASHIJIANJILU,DOUGOUBUCHENGSUOWEIFAXUELILUN,TAMENZHINENGSHIBEIFAXUELILUNSUOYAOJIAGONGDECAILIAO。ERDANGYUANYUFALVSHIJIANQIEGAOYUFALVSHIJIANDELILUNDANSHENGZHIHOU,WEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANDEFALVSHIJIANFANERDUIFALVLILUNBUWENBUWEN,YIWEIYIZHANGGUANYIZHIRENYIZUOWEI,QIZHISHIFALVLILUNDELANGFEI,GENGFALVSHISHIJIANDEBEIAI。YINWEIYANGESHUOLAI,BUZUNZHONGYIDINGLILUNDEFALVSHIJIANYUDONGWUDEHUODONGMEIYOULIANGYANG,TAZISHIJIUHELIXINGDONGWUDEXINGDONGWUGUAN。

WEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANZHIDAO,ZAIFAXUEJIE,XUEZHEMENYEYINWEI“JINGENSHIJI(JIAN)”,ERZAIQILUNZHU、XUESHUHUIYIHUOJIAOCAIZHONGCENGJINGYANJIU、TAOLUNHUOXIERUHE“YIGUOLIANGZHI”、“CHUJIJIEDUAN”、“YOUJIHUASHANGPINJINGJI”、“SHEHUIZHUYISHICHANGJINGJI”、“SHICHANGJINGJI”、“YIDEZHIGUO”、“JINGSHENWENMING”、“ZHENGZHIWENMING”DENGXIANGGUAN“FALIXUEWENTI”。CONGERFALIXUEYANRANCHENGWEISHEHUIZHENGZHISHIJIANDEXIANSHIZONGJIE。JINGUANZHEIZHONGQINGXINGZIXUESHUDUOYUANHUADEYAOQIUCHUFA,YEBINGWUBUKE,DANRUGUOZHANGQIYIWANG,FALIXUEJIFALIXUEJIAYONGYUANZHINENGSHIZHENGZHISHEHUISHIJIANDEJISHENGZHE,ERBUHUICHENGWEIFALVSHIJIANDEYUBAOZHE。

WEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANYIWEI,ZHIYOULIJIYUSHEHUI(FALV)SHIJIANZHISHANG,DANTONGSHIYOUCHAOYUEYU、DULIYUSHEHUI(FALV)SHIJIANDEFAXUELILUN,CAIKENENGCHENGWEIFALVSHIJIANDEXUESHUCANZHAOHEJINGSHENLILIANG,CHENGWEIFAZHIWEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANHEFALVYUNXINGDELILUNZHIDAO。ZAIYIDINGYIYISHANGJIANG,FALVLILUN“TUOLISHIJI”SHILISUODANGRANDE。DUICI,WEINISIGUANFANGWANGZHANCENGJINGXIEDAO: “JIERYANZHI,LILUNTANGRUOBUTUOLISHIJI,ZEYIWEIZHETABUSHILILUN,TAYEBUKENENGYIDULIPINGEFANGUOLAIZHIDAOSHIJIAN,JINERYUSHIJIAN‘JIEHE’。”[9]ZAICI,BUNANJIANBENRENZAIGAIWENTISHANGDEJIBENZHUZHANG。

以上的文字,只是在当代中国法学面对歧路横生的境遇时,笔者的一己主张,因此无意“指点江山”。对于选择了其他路线并成绩卓著者,威尼斯官方网站只有由衷的赞叹,威尼斯官方网站也会同情地理解和批判地宽容。